Bars VS Dumbbells: which one lets you lift more weight?

Bars VS Dumbbells: which one lets you lift more weight?

From the perspective of the weight lifted, you can’t compare barbell work to dumbbell work

If you can move 100 kg on flat bench press with a barbell, you won’t be able to lift 100 kg with dumbbells (2 x 50 kg) for the same number of reps.

One of the most common and accepted explanations is the need for a higher degree of stabilization in dumbbell exercises. However, although balance/stability is an obvious limiting factor for beginners, a more experienced athlete generally shouldn’t have major stability issues performing the exercise.

Difference between Barbell Vs Dumbbell Exercise

To understand the main kinetic difference between an exercise done with a barbell and dumbbells, it’s necessary to grasp the mechanical difference between the two, shown in the following table:

Open kinetic chain: dumbbells

OPEN KINETIC CHAIN: exercises where the end of the main joint involved in the movement (hand or foot) moves freely.

  • Examples: dumbbell exercises, leg extensions, leg curls…

In an open kinetic chain situation, external forces transmitted through the hands point directly downward due to gravity and lack of friction. That’s why it’s advised not to bring the dumbbells together at the peak contraction of a movement, since mechanical tension in the muscles is lost. It’s a way to rest.

The vertical forces create an external extension moment/torque at the elbow (biceps activity needed) and a large moment/torque at the shoulder joint.

IMAGEN 2 119º post

Closed kinetic chain: barbell

CLOSED KINETIC CHAIN: exercises where the end of the main joint involved in the movement (hand or foot) can’t move freely. There’s a “bond” preventing it (usually a barbell). Closed chain exercises tend to offer more athletic benefits.

  • Examples: barbell exercises (bench press, squats, 90º rows…), leg press…

In this case, forces usually also have a medio-lateral component due to friction and the bar itself, especially with a wide grip. These medio-lateral forces make up about 25% of the vertical forces throughout the range of motion.

That’s why, as you can see in the table above, the external force is more medial (oblique toward the chest) creating an external flexion moment/torque at the elbow (triceps activity needed) and a smaller moment arm for the shoulder.

IMAGEN 3 119º post

Conclusion

In the bench press example, triceps will be more involved when using the barbell, and the moment arm at the shoulder joint will be reduced compared to the same exercise done with dumbbells. The extra help provided by accessory agonist muscles makes it easier to move more weight with a barbell than with dumbbells, plus the lower stabilization demand. To give a few examples:

  1. Triceps help more in military press or bench press done with barbells than with dumbbells.
  2. Biceps help more in rows done with barbells than with dumbbells.

Sources

  • Cotterman, M. L., Darby, L. A., & Skelly, W. A. (2005). Comparison of muscle force production using the Smith machine and free weights for bench press and squat exercises. The Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 19(1), 169-176.
  • Krosshaug, T. (2012). Revealing “secrets” of strength training exercises with kinetic analysis. 8th International Conference on Strength Training. Oslo, Norway.
  • Saeterbakken, A. H., van den Tillaar, R., & Fimland, M. S. (2011). A comparison of muscle activity and 1-RM strength of three chest-press exercises with different stability requirements. Journal of Sports Sciences, 29(5), 533-538.
  • Santana, J. C., Vera-Garcia, F. J., & McGill, S. M. (2007). A kinetic and electromyographic comparison of the standing cable press and bench press. The Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 21(4), 1271-1277.
  • Schick, E. E., Coburn, J. W., Brown, L. E., Judelson, D. A., Khamoui, A. V., Tran, T. T., & Uribe, B. P. (2010). A comparison of muscle activation between a Smith machine and free weight bench press. The Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 24(3), 779-784.
Content Protection by DMCA.com
About Carlos Sánchez
Carlos Sánchez
Meet our author Carlos Sánchez, a graduate in Human Nutrition and Dietetics. All his actions are backed by science.
Check Also
Rare parameters in blood tests when using steroids
Rare parameters in blood tests when using steroids

In this post, we’re going to try to explain the changes in parameters when reading …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Exoneration of liability
This blog does not aim to give any medical suggestions, treatments, or diagnoses. Please consult with your doctor for any issues or questions about your health. The nature of the blog’s articles is merely informative, the articles do not constitute any medical diagnosis or treatment. The various authors of the blog’s articles expose their own opinions, and HSN does not determine the topic, the content, and the statements contained in the texts.
Health Registration No: 26.11001/GR
Health Registration No: 40.048706/GR
Health Registration No: 26.017818/O